“Work out and you’ll feel better” is something we hear a lot. But what does the research say? We looked at a large 2024 analysis in the BMJ that pooled 218 trials in people with clinical depression.
In short: In clinical depression, walking or jogging, yoga and strength training reduced symptoms moderately — about as much as therapy — and the effect grew with intensity. The studies are of low quality; exercise should be considered alongside medication or therapy, not instead of them.
What did the study do?
- Study
- Noetel et al., BMJ, 2024
- Type
- Network meta-analysis of randomised trials: a pooled analysis that compares many treatments at once
- Scope
- 218 studies, 495 groups, 14,170 people
- Who
- All met the clinical criteria for major depression
In each trial, participants were randomly assigned to exercise or another condition. Exercise was compared with “active controls” such as usual care or a placebo pill, and with therapy and medication in the same analysis.
What did it find?
| Exercise | Reduction in symptoms |
|---|---|
| Walking / jogging | Moderate (effect size 0.62) |
| Yoga | Moderate (0.55) |
| Strength training | Moderate (0.49) |
| For comparison: cognitive behavioural therapy | Moderate (0.55) |
An effect size is a standard measure of the difference between two groups; around 0.5 counts as “moderate”. Walking or jogging, yoga and strength training worked about as well as therapy. Dance showed the largest effect, but it rested on only 5 studies and 107 people; the authors highlight walking or jogging, yoga and strength training.
- Intensity: the harder the exercise, the stronger the effect. Even light exercise (walking, yoga) made a meaningful difference (0.58); vigorous exercise (running, intervals) did more (0.74).
- Sticking with it: yoga and strength training were the exercises people found easiest to keep doing.
Good to know
- Most studies were small with a high risk of bias; only one was low risk. Confidence in the evidence is therefore low for walking or jogging and very low for the others.
- The results don’t show that exercise replaces medication or therapy; the authors say it could be considered alongside them as a core treatment.
Source
- Noetel M, Sanders T, Gallardo-Gómez D, et al. (2024). Effect of exercise for depression: systematic review and network meta-analysis of randomised controlled trials. BMJ 384:e075847. doi:10.1136/bmj-2023-075847 · PubMed · Full text (PMC)
This article is for information only and is not medical advice. Talk to your doctor about decisions that concern your health.
